As Russia marks the third anniversary of its full-scale invasion of Ukraine, the world remains at a critical juncture, with questions looming about the path to peace and the future of Ukraine’s sovereignty. While international efforts to negotiate a ceasefire are intensifying, tensions around the terms of a potential agreement have only escalated. The war, which has reshaped both European security and international relations, has proven to be a costly endeavor for Russia, yielding both territorial gains and profound losses.

Russia’s Territorial Gains: The Cost of Occupation

One of the key gains for Russia in this prolonged conflict has been its territorial control. If a ceasefire were to freeze the conflict at its current state, Moscow would retain control of almost 20% of Ukraine’s land, including Crimea, annexed in 2014, and several regions in eastern and southern Ukraine. Russia has managed to occupy large portions of the Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson, and Zaporizhzhia oblasts, with ongoing efforts to “Russify” these areas by issuing Russian passports and broadcasting state-controlled media.

However, the future of these regions remains uncertain, especially as Ukraine seeks to reclaim its pre-2014 borders. U.S. Defense Secretary Hegseth recently stated that returning to Ukraine’s prior territorial boundaries is an unrealistic goal, signaling a shift in Western positions on what a peace deal might entail.

Natural Resources and Industry: A Valuable Takeover

Russia’s military advance has granted it access to Ukraine’s valuable natural resources. Control over the Donbas region, which houses much of Ukraine’s coal and metal resources, along with key industrial facilities, has been one of Russia’s most significant acquisitions. Furthermore, Russian forces have captured Ukrainian lithium deposits, a crucial resource in the global push for green technologies.

These resources are vital not only for the Russian economy but also for its strategic interests, as Moscow looks to expand its economic and military influence through these acquisitions. However, as the war progresses, the long-term sustainability of these gains is in question.

A Shift in Global Alliances and Economic Strain

The war has also had profound geopolitical repercussions, with Russia strengthening ties with non-Western powers like China, India, Iran, and North Korea. Moscow has presented itself as a leader of the “Global South,” advocating for a multipolar world order that challenges Western dominance in international affairs. Despite these alliances, Russia’s reputation on the global stage has suffered. The failure to secure a quick victory in Ukraine and the mounting casualties have exposed weaknesses in Russia’s military capabilities.

Economically, Russia is facing significant challenges. The war has drained resources, causing inflation, a surge in business bankruptcies, and a looming economic crisis. Russia’s military spending, while bolstering its defense capabilities, has come at the expense of civilian industries, pushing the economy toward stagnation.

NATO and Ukraine’s Security: A Complex Future

While Russia has achieved some short-term objectives, including halting Ukraine’s NATO membership ambitions, the conflict has paradoxically triggered NATO’s expansion. Finland and Sweden, long neutral, have now joined the alliance, effectively doubling NATO’s border with Russia. Ukraine’s security remains a critical issue, with Kyiv demanding binding security guarantees from the West to protect against future Russian aggression.

The United States, under President Joe Biden, has voiced its commitment to Ukraine’s sovereignty but has shown reluctance to offer NATO membership. Instead, European countries, including Britain and France, have discussed deploying a peacekeeping force to Ukraine to ensure its security in the event of a ceasefire.

Russia’s Domestic Struggles and Reputational Damage

Domestically, President Vladimir Putin’s approval ratings have soared despite the heavy toll the war has taken on Russian soldiers and the economy. However, the human cost of the conflict is staggering, with estimates of Russian casualties reaching up to 1.2 million, including both dead and wounded soldiers. Despite these losses, Russia has continued its offensive, relying heavily on poorly trained troops and mercenaries.

The war has also backfired on Russia’s broader strategy to suppress Ukrainian identity. Despite efforts to undermine Ukraine’s cultural ties and force deportations, the war has galvanized national pride among Ukrainians, strengthening their resolve for independence and sovereignty.

Looking Ahead: A Fragile Peace?

As the war drags on, both sides face immense pressure to reach a ceasefire agreement. For Russia, a negotiated peace may offer a temporary respite from its economic woes and military setbacks. However, it may also solidify the territorial status quo, with Russia retaining control of significant Ukrainian land and resources.

For Ukraine, a peace agreement without the restoration of its territorial integrity or NATO membership may feel like a bitter compromise, yet it could provide the stability needed to rebuild. Ultimately, the future of Ukraine remains uncertain as international diplomacy intensifies, with the stakes higher than ever for both Ukraine and Russia.

You also might be interested