Premier League clubs to extend trial of concussion substitutes to reserve and youth team level


Premier League clubs to extend trial of concussion substitutes to reserve and youth team level in October… in opposition of criticism from brain-injury campaigners

  • The Premier League trial started in February after approval from IFAB 
  • The rule stated that up to two permanent subs could be made for a head injury
  • The permanent nature of the substitutions have been criticised by campaigners 
  • This is because managers and players appear reluctant to use them in games


Premier League clubs will extend the trial of concussion substitutes to cover all reserve and youth-team matches from next month in defiance of criticism from brain-injury campaigners.

The top flight began the trial last February along with the FA after it was approved by international law-making body IFAB, with a rule introduced stating that up to two permanent substitutions could be made in the event of a head injury, even if all replacements had already been used. 

The permanent nature of the concussion substitutes has been criticised by campaigners, including Sportsmail columnist Chris Sutton and brain injury charity Headway, on the grounds that managers and players appear reluctant to use them.

Clubs will extend the trial of concussion substitutes to cover all reserve and youth-team matches from next month

Brain injury charity Headway questioned Aston Villa's handling of John McGinn's head injury

Brain injury charity Headway questioned Aston Villa’s handling of John McGinn’s head injury 

The first concussion substitution made in English football illustrated this fear clearly, as West Ham’s Issa Diop was not taken off until half-time of West Ham’s FA Cup tie against Manchester United last February, despite sustaining a head injury nine minutes earlier.

Headway also questioned Aston Villa’s handling of John McGinn’s head injury against Everton on Saturday.

Headway argue that following the example of rugby by allowing managers to make an unlimited number of temporary subs would make them far more proactive and increase player safety, but the Premier League appear reluctant to change course.

Read more at DailyMail.co.uk