Potato growers hope mustard and arugula combo will prevent pests and make soil healthier


New research on P.E.I. is using mustard and arugula to tackle pest problems in potato fields with a side benefit, farmers hope, of making the soil healthier at the same time.

And yes, it is very similar to the arugula in your salad, but the mustard has some added kick to it. 

The mustard in the field is called caliente rojo, and is specially bred to have high levels of glucosinolates, a natural component in many pungent plants including mustard, cabbage, and horseradish.

“In conventional mustards, they’re bred down so that they’re not quite as potent, but this is a variety that is specifically bred to have really high levels of those glucosinolates,” said Ryan Barrett, research and agronomy specialist with the P.E.I. Potato Board. 

Ryan Barrett holds a piece of arugula planted in one of the mustard field trials in Springfield West, P.E.I. (Shane Hennessey/CBC )

“When we incorporate this mustard into the ground as a green manure, it acts as what we call a natural biofumigant,” Barrett said. 

“Through that, we’re releasing that chemical into the soil. When it combines with water, it makes a gas, and that gas helps to kill bad micro-organisms and diseases in the soil.” 

Adding arugula

Barrett said there is just a small amount of arugula in the mix, but it has a very specific purpose, aimed at attracting nematodes. 

“Nematodes like to feed on the roots of arugula, so a little bit of it is put in the mixture so that it grows at the bottom of the canopy, and the nematodes go to that,” Barrett said.

“Then when we incorporate the mustard, those nematodes will be in that root zone where we’re incorporating. So they’ll be more exposed to the natural biofumigant gas.”

Barrett said this specific project started last year, with five fields across the Island, and those fields are in potatoes this year. (Shane Hennessey/CBC)

Barrett said the impact of the biofumigant is immediate, but also lasts for a couple of weeks.

“The grower here won’t plant anything else for about two weeks in this field to let that biofumigant take full effect,” Barrett said. 

“After about two weeks, he’ll plant another cover crop in here.”

The mustard is chopped with a flail mower first, into a fine chop of green material, then incorporated into the soil, where it comes into contact with soil moisture and releases the biofumigant gas. (Shane Hennessey/CBC)

Learning curve

Potato grower Brandon MacPhail has two farms with mustard this year, in Stanley Bridge and New London.

MacPhail said he has already learned a lot in his first year with the crop. 

“The timing for flailing it down, I had to borrow some equipment because our stuff’s not quite the same,” MacPhail said. 

“Pretty small seeds. It was a bit of a challenge to plant, and get everything right, but it grows pretty easy. The whole way it’s going to be a learning experience.” 

Potato grower Brandon MacPhail has two farms with mustard this year, in Stanley Bridge and New London. (Shane Hennessey/CBC)

MacPhail said he will be interested to see what kind of a difference the mustard makes. 

“I’d like to obviously see a yield increase. I’d like to see the plants perhaps healthier,” MacPhail said. 

“It’s a tough one, though, because it’s basically taking that field out of production for the year, of any cash crop. It’s a balancing act, but hopefully doing this maybe once in every two cycles might help down the road.”

Barrett said the impact of the biofumigant is immediate, but also lasts for a couple of weeks. (Shane Hennessey/CBC)

MacPhail said he likes the fact that mustard is a natural biofumigant. 

“It’s pretty nice being able to go that way instead of the other way with the sprayer,” MacPhail said.

“It’s kind of nice for the bees, too, because it’s pretty bright yellow fields right now.”

Better understanding

Barrett said this specific project started last year, with five fields across the Island, and those fields are in potatoes this year, and they’ve added another five fields, that will be in potatoes next year.

“Because last year was a dry year, that can throw off some of our field trials,” Barrett said. 

“If we’re doing things over multiple years, multiple parts of the province and multiple fields, we kind of spread that risk, and we hopefully get a better scientific understanding of what’s happening.”

Barrett said the mustard seed is costly, and the crop is also a lot of work, and needs to be incorporated into the soil at the right time. (Randy McAndrew/CBC)

Barrett said the ultimate goal is to give potato growers another tool in the toolbox — using crop rotation to manage some of the pests and diseases in their fields, including early dying disease.

But Barrett said the mustard seed is costly, and the crop is also a lot of work, and needs to be incorporated into the soil at the right time.

Barrett said researchers hope to have some preliminary results this fall. (Shane Hennessey/CBC)

“We’re trying to identify how well does the mustard work? What’s the economics of doing it? And can we measure the effect it’s having on some of the things that cause potatoes to die early, and lower yield?” Barrett said.

“If the return is enough, there’ll be more growers that would look at doing it, particularly for some of their worst affected fields.”

Barrett said researchers hope to have some preliminary results this fall.

More from CBC P.E.I.

Read more at CBC.ca