Legal experts warn case against Idaho suspect Bryan Kohberger isn’t ‘open and shut’


Legal experts have warned that the case against alleged Idaho killer Bryan Kohberger isn’t a ‘slam dunk’ – despite authorities discovering his DNA at the scene.

Kohberger, 28, was arrested on December 30 after weeks of painstaking investigation by police in Moscow, Idaho, and the FBI.

His DNA was discovered on the button of a knife sheath which was left at the scene of the crime next to the bodies of Kaylee Goncalves and Maddie Mogan.

Ex-federal prosecutor Neama Rahmani believes that those defending Kohberger will not present an insanity defense because of his history as a ‘scholar.’

Kohberger, 28, was arrested on December 30 after weeks of thorough investigation by police in Moscow, Idaho, and the FBI

Ex-federal prosecutor Neama Rahmani has said that the case against Kohberger is not a 'slam dunk'

Ex-federal prosecutor Neama Rahmani has said that the case against Kohberger is not a ‘slam dunk’  

The trial lawyer said: ‘The murder case against Bryan Kohberger is not a slam dunk. Kohberger’s attorney will most likely argue that he didn’t do it, rather than present an insanity defense.

‘He was accomplished enough as a scholar to become a Ph.D. student and he showed no indication of mental illness before the stabbings, so there would be little justification for his defense to argue he is incompetent to stand trial.

‘The authorities have Kohberger’s DNA on the knife sheath, but DNA evidence can be transferred from one person to another onto an object so that evidence is not open and shut for a conviction.

‘Prosecutors don’t have the murder weapon, they have a pretty vague description of the suspect from an eyewitness, and they lack a clear-cut motive.

‘If I was the D.A., I would certainly like a lot more than the evidence that has come out so far, especially if prosecutors are going to pursue the death penalty.’

It comes after the family of one victim, Kaylee Goncalves, say that they would support the death penalty in the case against Kohberger.

Former Los Angeles County prosecutor Joshua Ritter believes that the DNA and other corroborating evidence is a ‘very strong case’ against the alleged killer

Former Los Angeles County prosecutor Joshua Ritter believes that the DNA and other corroborating evidence is a ‘very strong case’ against the alleged killer

Cops detail his every move on the day of the killings, helped by surveillance footage of his car and cell site data from his phone. Kohberger allegedly staked out the property on twelve occasions before the murders

Cops detail his every move on the day of the killings, helped by surveillance footage of his car and cell site data from his phone. Kohberger allegedly staked out the property on twelve occasions before the murders

Police believe that Kohberger deliberately tried to hide his location during the murders

Police believe that Kohberger deliberately tried to hide his location during the murders

Her father Steve said that his vision of ‘justice’ is not to ‘be in a prison cell’, with her mother adding that she ‘wished Kaylee and Maddie were serving a life sentence’ because it would mean they could talk to them.

Rahmani added: ‘Prosecutors will continue to build the case, so I don’t think they will take the death penalty off the table.

‘It will be hard for Kohberger’s defense to reach any workable deal with prosecutors, so this case will most likely head to trial.’

Former Los Angeles County prosecutor Joshua Ritter, who is a partner with El Dabe Ritter Trial Lawyers, believes that the DNA and other corroborating evidence is a ‘very strong case’ against the alleged killer.

He said: ‘I can’t imagine this being a case where prosecutors don’t seriously consider the death penalty. 

‘In that scenario, the only way Kohberger would accept a plea deal would be if prosecutors take the death penalty off the table. But it’s a little early to talk about plea deals at this point.

Kohberger even returned to the scene of the crime at 9am on November 13 - just hours after he allegedly committed the quadruple murders. Pictured - Kaylee Goncalves and Maddie Mogen

Kohberger even returned to the scene of the crime at 9am on November 13 – just hours after he allegedly committed the quadruple murders. Pictured – Kaylee Goncalves and Maddie Mogen

The 28-year-old and his attorney, Anne Taylor, Chief Public Defender for Kootenai County, asked for the 1122 King Road property to remain sealed until February 1. Pictured together at court on Thursday

Idaho murders suspect Bryan Kohberger smiles at his attorney in court as he was denied bail. Kohberger will return to court on January 12 

‘This is one of those watershed cases where you have four young, good-looking, completely innocent victims in a small community who were horrifically stabbed to death.

‘If this had taken place in a huge metropolis like Los Angeles or New York it still would have received attention, but the fact that this took place in a small community seems to have added to the intrigue surrounding the murders.’

Kohberger previously insisted that he would be ‘exonerated’ to his lawyer in Pennsylvania.

It comes as law enforcement sources say the alleged killer was seen taking out garbage using surgical gloves several times at his parents home.

The officers were tasked with tracking Kohberger so they could arrest him as soon as a warrant was issued as well as trying to get hold of an object to compare DNA to a sample found at the scene.

The house in Moscow, Idaho. Bombshell documents reveal how police were led to the suspect

The house in Moscow, Idaho. Bombshell documents reveal how police were led to the suspect

Kohberger was seen cleaning the inside and outside of his car, with a law enforcement source adding that he didn’t ‘miss an inch’

Kohberger was seen cleaning the inside and outside of his car, with a law enforcement source adding that he didn’t ‘miss an inch’

Law enforcement saw him multiple times outside of his parent's Pennsylvania home wearing surgical gloves

Law enforcement saw him multiple times outside of his parent’s Pennsylvania home wearing surgical gloves

He was also seen cleaning the inside and outside of his car, with the source adding that he didn’t ‘miss an inch’.

Kohberger was also reportedly seen taking out the trash to his neighbour’s bins at around 4am – with the contents being recovered by offices.

matched the DNA found on the sheath to Kohberger’s by comparing it to his father’s DNA – which was a 99.9998 percent match.

The white Hyundai Elantra is one of the things that helped cops track down the alleged killer, as well as obtaining his phone records.

He yesterday appeared in court charged with the four murders as well as a felony burglary after being extradited to Idaho.

The criminal justice graduate only spoke to confirm his name and that he had representation during a hearing in Moscow, Idaho, on Thursday.

A timeline issued by police indicates that Kohberger managed to break into the house and kill al four victims within a 15-minute period, before his car was seen speeding off in surveillance footage.

Phone records show that Kohberger went close to the property just five hours after the murders were committed – with his phone being turned off during the time of the murders.

He is also accused of stalking the students and visiting the property or the area at least 12 times before the slayings on November 13.

Read more at DailyMail.co.uk